20 Ways to control slugs in the permaculture garden or on the allotment
Inundated with slugs in the wet weather? Permaculture designer, Ludwig Appeltans, gives 20 practical tips for controlling slugs so that you do get to eat your harvest.
There are many tips about how to fight these invertebrates circulating around allotments and gardens – some are fables, some are more effective than others. The reality is that no single thing does the trick. In short, the solution is to create an ecosystem in your garden that will help to create a balance. A plague is caused by an imbalance, a lack of predators that keep the population of slugs under control. Sounds easier than it is, but if you love your garden it greatly increases the joy and once established it looks after it self!
A number of years ago I started a forest garden in the middle of a very wet woodland, in the midst of a slug stronghold. I could easily collect a large jarful of slugs at dusk. After an intensive research and learning process with many failures, I only had to go out with a torch in the dark once every week or so and even then I only found a few. I was able to grow anything I liked without losing many plants to slugs. I have had to learn to live with some losses but still feel I can shout "Victory!"
Here is what I learned:
Step 1: know your enemy
There are a lot of different kinds of slugs and some are more harmful than others. The large black slug doesn't do much damage at all as they prefer rotting matter, dung and carrion above living plants. The garden slug is the opposite, attacking anything that even slightly resembles an herbaceous plant.
The most harmful slugs:
Some slug characteristics:
- Slugs don’t have teeth, so rasp vegetables rather than chew them. If it is very quiet you can hear them eat.
- Some experts claim that it is the younger slugs that do the most damage as older slugs eat more compost than green leaves. My experience is different – both are a nuisance. The big ones have grown big by eating my plants, so I make no distinction!
- Slugs are nomads, unlike snails who carry their home on their back but always go back to the same spot.
- They are nocturnal animals and during the day hide underneath flowerpots, stones, leaves etc.
- Because they have no skeleton they can squeeze through the tiniest holes – don’t make breathing holes in the slug collecting jar (as I painfully learned).
- Slugs eggs are gelatinous, mostly pale and can be found in small clusters under rocks, in plant containers and similar safe locations.
- Slugs love moisture and water. A dry garden at night time reduces the slug damage significantly. Consider watering the garden early in the morning.
Step 2: correct the imbalance
Introduce and encourage predators
This is the quickest, most effective, least labor intensive biological method to secure a slug free area for up to 6 weeks. One treatment for about 200 square meter costs a little more than £20 at the moment. Nematodes are microscopically small worms that parasitise and kill slugs. The nematodes are watered on to the soil surface, who then actively search for their prey and invade it. Special bacteria, living in symbiosis with the nematodes, are released, multiply rapidly and act as food for the nematodes. An infected slug stops feeding within 3 to 5 days and then displays a typical swelling. The nematodes multiply inside the slug and when it starts to decompose, a new generation of nematodes spreads and starts looking for the next prey. The nematodes work for up to 6 weeks.
This cure has a serious side effect though. It is too successful. By eliminating all the slugs, we also also taking away food for the predators that eat the slugs or its eggs and we drive away the predators in a hunt for food. The result of that is that we create the perfect scenario for a slug plague: An area rich in food for slugs with few predators. Party time! In effect we become addicted to the quite expensive cure. In my journey so far I have only used it in one garden and only on a small part of it, because the plague was so bad.
Having a pond in the garden has many benefits. It greatly increases wild life and the beauty. It allows birds and insects to drink. And you can grow food and flowers in the pond and on the edge. If you don’t keep fish, ducks or herons, you can keep frogs. Apparently it is illegal to collect frog spawn from the wild. I understand that wild life needs to be protected against ignorance so I want to encourage you to do loads of research for yourself and I won’t encourage you to go to pond nearest to your garden to gently and with great care collect only a little bit frog spawn with some pond water for your own haven for wild life. Frogs are only fertile after two years, so I will not encourage you to do it two years in a row. The little frogs hopping about hunting for slugs are delightful. It is a joy to see them! It encouraged me to thread gently in the garden, which can only be a good thing.
Toads do not need a pond. If you provide enough moist hiding spaces they will most likely be attracted by the abundance of food.
These beautiful creatures are becoming rare and are strictly protected. It really is not a good idea to pick them in the wild. So the only way to get them in your garden is to provide a good shelter and hope they turn up. A sheet of corrugated iron or black plastic in a slightly raised and sunny spot near the compost heap seems best (Dry and warm). Slow worms feed mostly on slugs. If you have them, protect them well they are a great ally!
There is an issue whether it is ethically justified to keep them in the perimeter of an allotment or garden. I think it is – if the hedgehog would otherwise have been culled and has a habitat that is able to provide it with all the essentials it needs. North Uist and Benbecula on the west coast of Scotland have had to take drastic steps to save the ground nesting birds as the hedgehogs were wiping them out by eating the eggs. Uist Hedgehog Rescue is a charity trying to save (deport rather than kill) hedgehogs from a certain death. I received the hedgehogs in the picture from the Hessilhead Wildlife Rescue Trust.
It is not easy to persuade them to give you a hedgehog as they want to come and look for themselves whether it is safe for hedgehogs. A road or badgers nearby would give you a negative reply.
If you are lucky enough to have a hedgehog, don’t treat it as a pet. It is a wild animal after all. A hag pile and some decent fencing to stop it going on the road is important as protection. Make sure there is enough food for it in the garden (don’t wipe out all the slugs), Don’t leave out cat food as it attracts vermin, don’t give it milk and don’t de-flea it as that would kill it.
Ducks are a great slug predator. Experts recommend the Khaki Campbells or Indian Runners who are the best carnivores – other breeds might eat more of your vegetables. Some people really swear by them and really recommend these animals. A good permaculture solution would be to have your garden in between the duck hut and the pen. Thereby allowing the ducks a good munch in the morning and evening while on the way to and from home. Ducks do eat frogs! Do not mix.
Carob beetles (Violet Ground beetle on the left and the Common Ground beetle on the right) are very effective slug predators – the larvae and beetles eat the eggs and the tiny slugs. If suitable homes are provided they can appear in huge numbers!
If you have these beetles in your garden, you can help them by providing a good home for them. Some patches between your beds with tough grasses or sedges, some straw or hay in an upside down plastic box, some stones for the beetles to live under, raised beds, well drained soil are all good. Try to make the access holes strong and tiny so that mice can’t get in (you can wrap the boxes with some fine mesh chicken wire). The beetles are tirelessly on the hunt all night!
Larger gardens or farms can encourage these animals by making a beetle bank.
Centipedes are carnivorous nocturnal hunters. Learn to distinguish between the millipedes and centipedes, as millipedes are herbivores and love young seedlings. The centipedes I know are harmless. Rumors or people being bitten are going around, but I have never met anyone who has been bitten by them. Centipedes like it moist so live in leaf litter, under stones, in rotting wood, etc. They are equipped with some ferocious weapons. I have only respect for them.
Control by distraction.
There are plants out there that slugs like better than your vegetables. If you grow them in your garden they will attract the slugs and all you will need to do is pick them up at dusk or put a slug trap nearby.
Lawn Camomile is my favorite because it is most effective in spring when my seedlings are small and most vulnerable. It is a perennial, so when the annuals are at the most vulnerable, the camomile is in full swing already. Rubbing the plant whilst looking for slugs releases the scent that attracts the slugs. I use it a lot.
Try to discover what slugs like better than your vegetables. Experiment with cut salad leaves and juicy plants left out between your plants.
Control by deportation or murder.
This part of the exercise is the most difficult an contentious. In the early part of my ‘career’ I used to catch slugs in a jar and deport them. Until I realized that, in essence I was transporting an imbalance from one ecosystem to another, thereby creating a problem elsewhere. For the sole reason that I was too much of a coward to deal with the problem myself and too afraid of a bad conscience and bad karma. I wasn’t even solving the problem cause deporting slugs and depositing them at a distance, creates a high slug pressure that get deflated by the low slug pressure that sucks them back in! Transporting them elsewhere is like mopping up water while the tap is running – now I kill them without mercy with a method as humane as I can come up with. After all, if there had been enough predators they would more than likely have fallen prey.
The most effective way of finding them is to go out with a torch just after dusk or at a miserable grey wet day– make sure to look on the underside of the vegetable leaves. Let the plant damage and slime trails guide you. I feed some to my frogspawn – they fight for them! (and I hope it helps them to develop a taste for slugs when they are older!)
Picking them by hand can be a messy business. Some species produce a slime that is really persistent. Some people use tongs, chopsticks or garden gloves.
These are a few of the most used murder weapons:
Jar: You can drown them by putting them in a jar filled completely with water and keeping the lid screwed on tightly. Some say soapy water kills them. A bucket with water is not good enough, the slugs will just crawl out again.
Knitting needles are useful to make slug sis kebab! (sorry)
Beer traps: After trying several designs this is the winner:
Slugs seem to get drunk and forget to crawl out again and drown.
The slugs are attracted by the fermentation gasses of beer. Any cheap lager or homebrew is good, though Ales and Guinness are best. Use a beer that has a good fermentation. The bait works even better when the slug corpses become part of the fermentation process. At that point it is rather smelly, yet effective, so top up the beer or replace after a while, as desired.
Beer of 2% is enough. If a higher percentage, dilute the beer with water.
Other creatures fall in somes too, especially the predator beetles mentioned above. They don’t get drunk and do want to get out again – a stick helps as an exit ladder. Also try to make sure that the entry holes are a bit above soil level. Slugs have no problem with the smooth plastic surfaces, unlike other creatures.
Place the traps at the edge of the beds. If you place them in the middle, slugs might get distracted by your juicy vegetables on the way to the pub.
Other traps: Many other traps can be used. Grapefruit halves, flower pots, cardboard, anything dark and moist will be favored by the slugs as a hiding place during the day. Inspect and capture at your leisure.
Sharp knife: My preferred method at the moment is a sharp knife. I use it flick the slugs of the plant onto the soil surface and behead the poor things. I think it is the quickest death and the most convenient as a pocket knife is easily carried on you as standard gardener equipment.
Copper: Slugs don’t like to crawl over copper. With some cleverness, one can come up with some really effective borders. A dozen or so pennies stuck into the soil around a seedling can form a border. A stripped electrical cable is even better and cheaper. With some imagination a seedling or potting table can be very large and still only have 4 legs, with copper cable wound around them.
To protect a precious plant, strip an old cable from it’s plastic insulation – you can use a proper stripping tool, but I press it against a hot wood burning stove until it is soft and then strip it using my fingernails or a knife. Cut the top and the bottom of a recycled plastic bottle. Wrap the cable a few times around it with one or two loops in it, fasten it to the bottle with duck tape through the loops and flatten the copper loops to the plastic – done! Dig the plastic in the soil so that slugs don’t crawl underneath.
Tip: If you use sticks to support the plant, wrap copper around the sticks too. Make sure none of the leaves touch the ground or any weeds touch the plant. Slugs can’t fly but they know how to find shortcuts!
The sharp edges of eggshells help as a deterrent, but only when they are clean and dry. When peeling an egg, try to remove the inner membrane and rinse if needed. I put them in an empty cooking pot on my wood burning stove to help dry them out. Be aware that rain quickly makes the eggshells lose their effectiveness.
Slug repellent plants:
Some plants are better at repelling than others. I read reports on the internet that conflict with my experience. I know that chives work well. They are easily laid or tied around plants as well. I am experimenting further and will add my experience to this page.
Many suggestions like: wood ash, sharp sand, charcoal dust, charcoal left overs after a barbecue, lava rock, are being made, most only work when the garden is dry. As I live and work mostly in Scotland I have not bothered to investigate these options as they are not that useful to me. Borders that stop working when the ideal slug environment has arrived seem a bit pointless to me.
Do not try:
Salt: Pouring salt around your veg will keep the slugs away indeed, but unless your plants like maritime conditions they will die too!
Seashells: The sharp edges deter slugs from crossing, but they don’t decay like eggshells and can be a serious nuisance when weeding for many years to come.
Slug pellets: Most are not organic and will kill the predators too. Even the organic ones are not wise to use: when the slugs die, the predators leave to find food elsewhere – leaving you dependent on the pellets.
Step 3: Enjoy watching your plants grow!
And please be grateful to your new found allies for the help.
Ludwig Appeltans is a permaculture designer and teacher. He has studied with Patrick Whitefield and trained with Designed Visions and writes a regular blog at http://earth-ways.co.uk. He is passionate about protecting and caring for the environment. To learn more about him see http://earth-ways.co.uk/about/
Enjoyed this article? Subscribe to our FREE monthly 'Best of Permaculture Online' e-newsletter or download a free back issue of our quarterly Permaculture magazine at http://www.permaculture.co.uk/
I made a slug electric fence around the base of a table. I keep my young/valuble plants on the table.
To do this I got some thin copper tube off ebay, http://bit.ly/KB2LwV and some panel pins.
I Got a big solid bit of wood as the base of the table and pinned two circles of the copper around the bit of wood. Make the circles about .5mm from each other.
I got a old car battery and stuck a cheap solar panel on it connect +/- to each of the bits of copper.
Put the copper right up under the table where it is not going to get rained on. Every month or so disconnect the battery and scrape off any dead slugs.
It's a bit of a faff to set up, but once you have done it you are pretty much guaranteed a slug-free area.
Another barrier I've had some success with has been human hair (yes, I cut my own so keep the clippings, and don't use any chemical treatments on it). I spread a good handful around the vulnerable plant and then lay a twisted loop of copper wire on top to stop it blowing around, and of course add an extra level of security. Seems to work fine, and of course the hair will eventually get incorporated into the soil.
Useful article, and some ideas I've yet to try, thank you!
Great article, I especially like the copper wire one, I've tried it before but I think the wire area wasn't wide enough. Nice idea with the plastic bottle slug gaurds.
Permagriculture, I don't mean to question you're method but it sounds like you're short circuiting a car battery with copper? If so I thought that was one of those things that you're not ever meant to do, I could be wrong.
fabulous article, but you mentioned ducks and no other birds ??
I always suggest to people to have a bird bath in their gardens to encourage birds to the area. When they visit for a drink and a bath they look around for something to eat. This is a great way to control many chewing insects.
Thanks for your great info, Cath.
Used coffee grounds can be collected from most Starbucks Costa etc....they bag up the grounds for grateful gardeners....create a barrier along borders or directly around plants as the coffee acts as a fertilizer ...a good way of reducing landfill too.
Your lawn will love being sprinkled with the grounds and earthworms see it as fine dining.
I have tried many "solutions" over the years. I heard today of putting rolled oats on the garden. The theory being that the slugs eat them and die. This does not then kill the hedgehogs when they eat the slugs. Will give it a go and report back.
Thank you for all your excellent additional suggestions. I am going to make the bottle slug trap. I have used small yoghurt pots before but they fill up with water. I like the idea of using a small plastic (cast off) bottle.
It sounds counter-intuitive, but making places for slugs to hole up during the day helps a lot. That way you know where to find them whenever you want them and don't have to bother going round the garden at night with a torch. Bits of wood, plastic or stone on the ground or laid up against each other seem to be preferred. By coincidence, this also provides habitat for a lot of slug predators.
Once I've got them I tend to put them on the bird table on the theory that doing that keeps the nutrients within the system (in the absence of ducks).
One more thing to add: sheep's wool makes a barrier that genuinely does seem to work in the wet as well as the dry. Supposedly they don't like the lanolin.
Great article. Cheers Ludwig.
Great article, informative and comprhensive thanks!!
Previously i have collected beer from my local pub when they empty the drip trays at the end of the evening..
I dont know whether other people have found this, but i have found copper works better if you clean it to make it shiny again every year..
Informative article Ludwig, thanks! And great to read about everyone's ways with slugs.
As well as developing balanced habitats for all creatures in the hope they will keep themselves under 'control' I do not mind the slugs having some of our grub. I tend to leave a few tender leaves around when I harvest in the hope they will eat them and be satisfied.
I have built a few frog/toad homes and installed a pond that has a small, dark, stone lined alley that connects the pond to the Polytunnel. The pond gets topped up with rain water run off from the Polytunnel when it rains and over flows into a nearby swale.
With this setup I have seen a increase in frog and toad numbers in the past year. Happy slug hunting to one and all! :) Jo